Is Dark Souls 3 Better Than Elden Ring? Comparison Guide

Is Dark Souls 3 better than Elden Ring? Let’s take a look and find out!

Elden Ring has been the talk of the town until just recently. The game has riled countless fans of the Dark Souls franchise into its unique yet familiar world. However, is it really the “better” continuation to Dark Souls 3, or is Dark Souls 3 still the better game? Let’s find out!

Guide Contents

Is Dark Souls 3 Better Than Elden Ring?

Dark Souls 3 is significantly better than Elden Ring in terms of music design. However, both titles are riddled with elements that make them fall short of becoming the perfect game to play. In the end, Dark Souls 3 tends to take the lead when both are compared.

Needless to say, there have been a lot of new factors introduced in FromSoftware’s latest title. While some of them have worked out brilliantly, others have unfortunately ruined the experience for many.

In this article, we will look at the factors that make Dark Souls 3 better than its successor. With that said, let’s jump in and get started!

What Makes Elden Ring So Different?

Elden Ring was intended to redefine the Dark Souls genre into something much more than what the platform has previously offered. While the direction it took wasn’t really the best one, it has still been an amazing game to play nonetheless.

Having said that, the introduction of open worlds makes it hard for you to feel the same sense of crisis that used to come with each passing mission. The side bosses are extremely weak n Elden Ring, whereas the main bosses are just as strong as the ones in Dark Souls 3.

However, the addition of dynamic mechanics like newer items and extra tools have significantly slowed the pace of the game. Rather than fighting your worst nightmares, you’re mostly busy trying to find certain NPCs and items in the vast world.

Why Is Dark Souls 3 So Fun?

Non-open-world games like Dark Souls 3 restrict the user’s movement to follow an intended path. While this saps away the joy of exploration, it also allows the developers to handcraft a unique experience for the game’s player base.

While this is present to a certain degree in open-world games, you just can’t expect everyone to follow the same trend. For example, some people might head to point A after defeating a boss, whereas some might look to explore the location.

Consequently, others can go and challenge a different boss that’s not tuned according to the player’s levels. The point is that giving too much control to the player makes it hard to fine-tune everything to perfection. Thus, the experience in Elden Ring is not as iconic as the one in DS3.

How Good Is Dark Souls 3 Compared To Elden Ring?

The difference isn’t that much apparently. Both games excel at their intended purposes. While Elden Ring leaves a void to be filled, it’s not a bad game by any means. Rather, it’s extremely fun to play in its own regard. But when it’s compared to titles like Dark Souls 3 – much is left to be desired.

Dark Souls 3 does what it is supposed to do and elevates it even further by creating iconic moments that stick with the player till the very end. Whereas Elden Ring amplifies the visual appeal of a rotten world to provide a compelling story and experience to its player base.

Both are essentially doing the same. It’s just that Dark Souls 3 executes it better.

Conclusion

All in all, Dark Souls 3 is better than Elden Ring. However, it doesn’t mean it’s the best title in FromSoftware’s arsenal. It’s not perfect by any means and tends to show in the game’s minor subtleties.

Looking for more Elden Ring guides? Here’s some more:

Elden Ring is available to play on Steam here.